Keep up to date with the latest news delivered direct to your Inbox.
Doormen Accused Of Unlawfully Killing Clubber
7:04am 8th October 2014
A 48-year-old man died on a Newquay pavement in a pool of his own blood after being restrained by four door staff from a club, a court has heard.
Keen angler Michael ‘Mick’ Kearns died during a night out on April 27, 2013.
At Truro Crown Court on Tuesday, Lewis Bowns, 26, Richard Favetta, 30, Ian Harold, 45, and Graham Lutey, 34, went on trial accused of unlawfully killing him.
Opening the case to the jury, Simon Laws, QC, for the Crown Prosecution Service, said there was not really any doubt that what the four men had done in the early hours of that morning had killed him.
He said: “Your task in the course of this case will be to decide whether what they did was criminal or, whether as they say, it was not.”
Mr Laws said Mr Kearns had been inside Sailor’s with friends prior to the incident and that he had assaulted a man with a stool, which led to him being ejected from the club.
Bowns, of Lewarne Road, Newquay, Favetta, of Penmere Road, Newquay, Harold, of Fernhill Road, Newquay and Lutey, of Summercourt, are accused of unlawfully killing Mr Kearns by gross negligence in that having restrained him on the ground and held him there against his will they owed a duty of care to him.
They are accused of being in breach of that duty of care by failing to ensure that Mr Kearns could breathe; that breach of duty amounted to gross negligence and that that negligence was a substantial cause of the death of Mr Kearns.
They are also all accused of a second, alternative charge of manslaughter, having unlawfully killed Mr Kearns.
All four deny the charges.
Mr Laws said in interview each told officers that Mr Kearns had been putting up a struggle on the ground and that police took too long to arrive, having been called following the assault inside the club..
The trial, which is expected to last up to four weeks, continues.
You can read more about the case here.7:04am 8th October 2014
Share This StoryTweet
Murder Accused Harboured "Fascination With Fire"
The trial has started of the woman accused of killing pensioner Gladys Rowe in Truro
WATCH: Ride To Remember Cornwall Singer Killed In Crash
Rivers Reeves friends and family have left Penzance...
UPDATE: Further Remains Found After Discovery Of Human Foot
Police are now searching the stream bed in woods near Truro
UPDATE: 'Severed' Foot Found Near Truro
A dog walker made the grim discovery in woods
WATCH: Fog Warning For Cornwall
Cornwall News: Forecasters says the drive to work could be difficult
GDP figures to show impact of Brexit vote
National News: Third quarter GDP figures due out later are expected to show the UK has managed to avoid a major economic slowdown following the Brexit vote.
Business Cornwall News - Friday, 18th December 2015
Business Cornwall News: Cornwall is spearheading reform of the Uk’s business licensing laws following a a year-long project.
Candice Brown declared winner of BBC's final Bake Off series
Showbiz News: Candice Brown has been crowned champion of the Great British Bake Off, which aired for the last time on the BBC tonight.
British banker Rurik Jutting 'waved knife at pedestrians after killings'
World News: Former British banker Rurik Jutting collapsed on his balcony after struggling to cut the throat of his second victim, before brandishing his knife at people walking below, his murder trial has heard.
Murray wins Vienna opener against Klizan
Sports News: Andy Murray is through into the second round of the Erste Bank Open, the Austrian tournament he is using to bolster his bid to become world number one.
PHOTOS: Is Pineapple Carving The Next Big Thing This Halloween?
Strange News: People are sharing their creations online
97mph Driver Won't Face Fine - Because They're Foreign
Cornwall News: Driver clocked speeding on the A30 at Temple among 700 who escaped a fine in Cornwall and Devon