Keep up to date with the latest news delivered direct to your Inbox.
Rubbish Row Secrecy Criticised
7:02am 10th December 2012
Pirate FM has been told we may never know the true extent of Cornwall's rubbish row.
The council got tens of thousands of calls about missed collections when a new system was brought in.
Back in April County Hall said the private contractor could face a fine.
But now officials are refusing to tells Pirate FM how much that is because it is still negotiating with the private company in charge of the collections, Cory.
It said the decision will be reviewed in April, a year after the problems, but could not promise that the figures would be released then either.
Robert Oxley from the Taxpayers Alliance said: "The service fell well short of what they would have expected. They have to hold those people making the decisions and those people providing the services to account. So I think taxpayers have an absolute right to this knowledge and it's disgraceful the council isn't publishing the information.
"If the council isn't being open and upfront about its spending on bins and whether it's getting the contracts right, how can taxpayers trust them to be open and transparent about other issues? It speaks volumes that the council isn't willing to disclose this information."
Cornwall Council said that nobody would be available for interview because Pirate FM is in the process of challenging the decision to withhold the information.
In a letter explaining its reasons for not releasing the information, despite telling the media in April that "further updates will be provided in the coming weeks", the Council said: "The data is still being reviewed, agreed and completed with Cory and therefore is not in a position to be released. The review includes a breakdown of the various contract elements such as garden, clinical, recycling and residual waste. The data will be reviewed in April and at that time consideration will be given as to whether this can be made publicly available.
"Although the Council receives a number of missed collection reports, this information needs to be verified as on subsequent investigation there are a number of missed collections that turn out to not be the fault of Cory, (e.g. the householder putting out their waste after the collection lorry had completed the round). By releasing inaccurate and incomplete data at this time would give a false picture of how the contract was performing and would prejudice the ongoing discussions concerning potential deductions and service levels."
In April the Council released part of the information requested, telling the media that "The latest figures show Cory have successfully completed over 1.3 million collections of refuse, recycling, garden waste and clinical waste over the last three weeks – this equates to 98.5% of the scheduled number of collections."
Some councillors have told Pirate FM they support the release of the information. Councillor Andrew Wallis said, "I'm finding it hard to even believe because Cory run the waste contract on behalf of the Cornish taxpayer. We pay them basically. I can't understand why the public shouldn't have that information."
Despite an extension the council missed a legal deadline to supply the information or explain its reasons for withholding it. Pirate FM was told this was because of sickness within the department responsible.7:02am 10th December 2012
Share This StoryTweet
WATCH: Helen Glover's Rowing Partner Retires
The Penzance star says Heather Stanning is "dependable and determined"
PHOTOS: This Little Guy Was Dumped Out With The Rubbish
The RSPCA says another gerbil could not be saved near Newquay
UPDATE: Woman Pulled From The Sea At Polzeath
Cornwall News: She was airlifted to Treliske on Sunday but doctors could not save her
Supreme Court told key Government power 'not an ancient relic'
National News: The powers invoked by the Government to begin divorce procedures from the European Union are not an out–of-date "ancient relic" but a pillar of the British constitution, the Attorney General has told the Supreme Court.
Business Cornwall News - Friday, 18th December 2015
Business Cornwall News: Cornwall is spearheading reform of the Uk’s business licensing laws following a a year-long project.
Bob Dylan wants speech read at Nobel ceremony that he won't attend
Showbiz News: Bob Dylan has sent a speech to be read out at the Nobel prize banquet that he has declined to attend.
How did gate stolen from Dachau concentration camp end up in Norway?
World News: Police investigating how an iron gate stolen from a Nazi concentration camp in Germany ended up in Norway say they have no evidence to work on.
Grieving Brazilian town honours plane crash victims
Sports News: Thousands of people have attended a service at a football stadium in Brazil to pay tribute to those who died in a plane crash.
Giant foam 'blob' leaks from airport hangar and spreads in Santa Clara
Strange News: A giant 'blob' of foam has taken over the streets of a Californian town after leaking from an airport hangar.