Pirate FM News

Duke of Cornwall Title Could One Day Be Female

charles

Published by the Pirate FM News Team at 7:01am 5th November 2013 (Updated 7:11am 5th November 2013)

One day we could have a female Duke of Cornwall.

A powerful committee of MPs says it is ridiculous a woman ca not inherit the title.

It is traditionally given to the heir to the throne and has been since the fourteenth century.

The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) warned that the institution is not keeping pace with constitutional changes: "The Duchy would benefit from being brought into the present-day to allow a female heir to the British Crown to bear the title 'Duke of Cornwall'."

Meanwhile, the Duchy of Cornwall does not possess a "competitive advantage" over other businesses despite being exempt from hefty taxes, a spokesperson for Prince Charles' estate has told Sky News.

The comments come as the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) today publishes its report on the accounts of the 700-year-old Duchy of Cornwall estate.

Under the Duchy, established in 1337 by King Edward III, the heir to the throne is exempt from paying corporation and capital gains taxes on land and property transactions.

But while the current Duke of Cornwall, Prince Charles, is technically exempt from paying income tax, he has volunteered to do so since 1993.

The Duchy spokesperson told Sky News: "We do not believe we have a competitive advantage.

"The Duke of Cornwall's income is taxed at income tax rates. The Duchy is not subject to corporation tax and the Duchy is not a corporation... any capital gains have to be reinvested in the business and cannot be distributed."

But the PAC's Margaret Hodge MP wonders whether the Duchy's unique tax arrangements allow for a level playing field when the estate stands alongside other businesses.

She said: "If you're letting property to a Holiday Inn in Reading or to Waitrose to run a big depot on an industrial estate, are the terms of that enabling other competitors in that market to compete on an equal and level playing field?

"What started off 700 years ago as a medieval estate, today demonstrates all the features of a modern big corporation, yet it hangs on to old habits such as exemption from corporation tax."

The Duchy’s main activity is the management of land and properties which make up its estate, providing an income for the present and future Dukes of Cornwall.

Its portfolio is made up of 131,000 acres of land, properties spread across 24 counties and more than 3,500 individual lettings.

All together over the last financial year it generated £28.8m and the Prince received an income of £19m, up 4% on the previous year.

The money is partly used to fund his and his family's public, charitable and official duties and the Prince voluntarily pays income tax on the cash left after costs, around £9.2m last year, according to the PAC.

Margaret Hodge believes the Treasury falls short of proper scrutiny when it comes to the Duchy's finances.

She said: "It [The Treasury] relies on the Duchy to provide it with accurate information without carrying out its own independent checks.

"Details of the Treasury's approvals for the Duchy's proposed land transactions over £500,000, of which there are around 15 a year, are not published.

"Greater transparency is needed."

In answer to the PAC findings, the Treasury said: "HM Treasury's role is to ensure that the Duchy of Cornwall is managed in a sustainable way and that the strategic choices made by the estate's managers are in its long-term interests and those of current and future dukes.

"The Treasury has a constructive working relationship with the Duchy, and challenges decisions where appropriate."

some great deals from pirate fm
Email Icon

Sign up for exclusive news, competitions and offers.
Proper Local News updates from Pirate FM

Suggested articles

Homes being built faster in Cornwall than anywhere else

Cornwall News: Around 2,500 houses are being built here every year

New tracker to tackle bed-blocking in Cornwall

Cornwall News: Around 20 patients a day are waiting to leave wards

Trending in Cornwall

Huge fire tears through bungalow in Cornwall

Crews had reports of people trapped at Bugle

VIDEO: Mass rip current rescues off Cornwall

Seven people were caught at Holywell and Perran Sands

LIVE: Car crash leaves Westminster on lockdown

Man questioned on suspicion of terror offences

Man dies after a 'freak accident' in Cornish woods

Police confirm he was struck by a tree at Tehidy

Robbery at jewellers in Penzance town centre

Items were stolen and police are searching for the suspect

PHOTOS: Abusive messages left on poorly parked car

Dead fish and dog poo were also left on the vehicle in St Ives

WATCH: The Red Arrows return to Falmouth

Check this full guide to travel and the best views

WATCH: Britain's Got Talent is back in Cornwall

This could be your time to shine...

Man treated by paramedics after an A38 crash

Police say a digger hit the barrier near Liskeard

Homes being built faster in Cornwall than anywhere else

Around 2,500 houses are being built here every year

More news...

Pirate Extra Pirate 70s Escape LoveCornwall