Keep up to date with the latest news delivered direct to your Inbox.
St Austell Shopping Centre Refused
5:52am 17th January 2014
(Updated 5:52am 17th January 2014)
The man whose vote blocked a controversial out of town shopping centre in St Austell has told Pirate FM too much of Cornwall would have suffered.
After a six hour meeting planners were evenly split about Coyte Farm - which might have meant big names like Primark and Marks and Spencer.
With votes split exactly down the middle, chair Rob Nolan stepped in to break the deadlock.
He said: "I think it is the right decision because it would have been in competition with St Austell town centre. The figures from our expert told us it would take 30% of the trade away from St Austell town centre and, for small shops, that's enough to finish them off in my view.
"The figures suggest it was going to take money out of Bodmin, Liskeard, further afield small villages. It would be a convenient place to go to and a lot of places would suffer."
The £110m scheme would also have included a supermarket, restaurant and hotel.
High street traders had argued it was too big and would destroy their businesses.
Jessica Milne speaks for locals who wanted it built and says it is a blow: "Rather than immediately jumping to the idea that this is going to be a devastating thing to the town centre and destroy farmland, considering the history of St Austell and the years of decline you have to look at it and look at the benefits and weigh up the pros and cons and decide which is better.
"Saying no to something is what this town has historically done a lot and I really believe you have to have a positive yes vibe sometimes in order to be seen as a town that is encouraging of investment, of wanting young people to work and live here. To generally be a welcoming place that invites growth."
This is not necessarily the end of the road for the controversial scheme.
Developers can appeal against the decision or submit a fresh plan in a couple of years time.
But supporters fear by then the big name chains will have moved elsewhere in Cornwall.5:52am 17th January 2014
Share This StoryTweet
BREAKING: Cornish MP describes "shocking" Westminster attack
Cornwall News: It is being treated as terrorism
Child sex offence recorded by police every 10 minutes, NSPCC says
National News: A child sex offence is recorded by police every 10 minutes in the UK, according to the NSPCC.
Kesha suffers another setback in court battle with Dr Luke
Showbiz News: Singer Kesha has lost another round in her legal battle against record producer Dr Luke, who she accused of rape and abuse.
Westminster attack: social media unites #wearenotafraid #prayforlondon
World News: Social media users around the world have united in a show of support for the people of Britain following the terror attack in London that left at least three victims dead.
Cornish Pirates Set For 'Tricky Customer'
Cornwall News: They are playing Nottingham in a New Year's Eve clash
Nicole Kidman explains her Oscars 'seal clapping' was to protect a ring
Strange News: Nicole Kidman has explained her "awkward" seal-like clapping during the Oscars ceremony last month.
UPDATE: Cornish Children's Centres Earmarked For Closure
Cornwall News: Council says respite care in Redruth and Truro is not providing value for money