Pirate FM News

Keep up to date with the latest news delivered direct to your Inbox.

Doormen Accused Of Unlawfully Killing Clubber

PirateFM news logo wide
Submit this page to redditDelicious

7:04am 8th October 2014

A 48-year-old man died on a Newquay pavement in a pool of his own blood after being restrained by four door staff from a club, a court has heard.

Keen angler Michael ‘Mick’ Kearns died during a night out on April 27, 2013.

At Truro Crown Court on Tuesday, Lewis Bowns, 26, Richard Favetta, 30, Ian Harold, 45, and Graham Lutey, 34, went on trial accused of unlawfully killing him.

Opening the case to the jury, Simon Laws, QC, for the Crown Prosecution Service, said there was not really any doubt that what the four men had done in the early hours of that morning had killed him.

He said: “Your task in the course of this case will be to decide whether what they did was criminal or, whether as they say, it was not.”

Mr Laws said Mr Kearns had been inside Sailor’s with friends prior to the incident and that he had assaulted a man with a stool, which led to him being ejected from the club.

Bowns, of Lewarne Road, Newquay, Favetta, of Penmere Road, Newquay, Harold, of Fernhill Road, Newquay and Lutey, of Summercourt, are accused of unlawfully killing Mr Kearns by gross negligence in that having restrained him on the ground and held him there against his will they owed a duty of care to him.

They are accused of being in breach of that duty of care by failing to ensure that Mr Kearns could breathe; that breach of duty amounted to gross negligence and that that negligence was a substantial cause of the death of Mr Kearns.

They are also all accused of a second, alternative charge of manslaughter, having unlawfully killed Mr Kearns.

All four deny the charges.

Mr Laws said in interview each told officers that Mr Kearns had been putting up a struggle on the ground and that police took too long to arrive, having been called following the assault inside the club..

The trial, which is expected to last up to four weeks, continues.

You can read more about the case here.

7:04am 8th October 2014

Share This Story

Submit this page to redditDelicious
Suggested articles
st merryn death

Cornish pensioner sentenced for killing wife

A judge has described the case as "very sad"

padstow death

Cornish pensioner who killed wife given hospital order

Douglas Addison was charged with her murder

Most read
storm waves 2

LIVE: Wind warning for the whole of Cornwall

Attraction shut and major event postponed

city of lights

WATCH: Truro City of Lights postponed

Bosses say it's 'not safe' for the event to go ahead this week

Top articles

LIVE: Wind warning for the whole of Cornwall

Cornwall News: Attraction shut and major event postponed

Pirate FM Cornwall News Update - 7th January 2016

Cornwall Video News: Officials say they’re holding talks to find new jobs for hundreds of workers in Bodmin.

Labour MP Angela Rayner celebrates being a grandmother at 37

National News: Labour's shadow education secretary Angela Rayner has expressed her joy at becoming a grandmother at the age of 37.

UPDATE: Body found on popular Cornish beach

Cornwall News: Police say death at Watergate Bay 'isn't suspicious'

David Cassidy, 1970s teen idol and The Partridge Family star, dies

Showbiz News: David Cassidy, whose role in the 1970s show The Partridge Family earned him teen heart-throb status, has died aged 67.

US Navy C-2 aircraft carrying 11 crashes into Pacific

World News: A US Navy aircraft carrying 11 crew and passengers has crashed into the Pacific Ocean, the US 7th Fleet said.

WATCH: NXT women crash title match between Charlotte Flair and Natalya

Sports News: There was more chaos in the WWE this week as SmackDown followed Raw in being invaded and attacked by NXT.

West Ham fans warned not to ring 999 as Watford defeat prompts emergency call

Strange News: West Ham fans have been warned by police not to call 999 over their team's poor performance.

Newer article

Congratulations Sir Ben!

Cornwall News: Cornwall's Sir Ben Ainslie announces he is engaged to TV presenter

Older article

97mph Driver Won't Face Fine - Because They're Foreign

Cornwall News: Driver clocked speeding on the A30 at Temple among 700 who escaped a fine in Cornwall and Devon

Pirate Extra Pirate 70s Escape LoveCornwall