Pirate FM News 4 minute read

Coastal deaths: RNLI faces "impossible situation"

Coastal deaths: RNLI faces "impossible situation"

Published by Sarah Yeoman at 6:03am 27th May 2020.

The RNLI says it does not have the power to stop people from going to beaches, following two tragic deaths on Cornwall's coast.

A 17-year-old local girl lost her life after getting trapped under an overturned inflatable boat on the Camel Estuary.

Elsewhere a man also died at Treyarnon Bay after he was pulled from the sea.

Another man was also helped from the water by surfers at Porthtowan and remains in hospital with life-changing injuries.

All three incidents unfolded in quick succession on bank holiday Monday.

Now the RNLI has revealed that it was only told about the easing of lockdown measures at the same time as the public.

The charity has not been able to train up lifeguards ready to patrol beaches because of the pandemic and the restrictions.

There is currently no lifeguard cover on beaches, but chief executive Mark Dowie has confirmed some patrols will now start up again from this weekend.

It follows reports that the RNLI was calling for beach bans, and for the government to restrict access to the coast, because of the lack of lifeguard cover.

Mark Dowie explained that the message is more about water safety and that 'safety advice and warnings will only go so far'.

lifeguards season ends

His open letter reads:

"Dear Sir/Madam,

"Despite our warnings that there were no lifeguards on patrol this weekend, crowded beaches, hot weather and big waves meant our lifeboat crews had their busiest weekend so far this year. At least two people lost their lives.

"This puts the RNLI in an impossible situation. With thousands flocking to English beaches now lockdown restrictions have been eased, we must strike a balance that keeps the public and our lifeguards safe.

"Safety advice and warnings will only go so far when people are desperate to enjoy some freedom after weeks of lockdown. But, as a lifesaving charity, the RNLI cannot stop people going to beaches.

"Rolling out a lifeguard service – especially in a pandemic – is not as simple as putting a lifeguard on a beach. We found out about the easing of lockdown restrictions in England at the same time and in the same way as the general public. Contrast that with shops, which were given three weeks’ notice and even car showrooms have been given 7-days warning to prepare.

"We have to work out how to do in-water rescues and give first aid – normally conducted at close quarters and often with people coughing up water. We have to find PPE that will work on a beach and in the water – visors and aprons are no good on a rescue board. And we have to train our lifeguards in procedures to reduce the risk of infection. All this takes time and we learnt of the lifting of restrictions at the same time as everyone else.

"Lifesaving is our priority. But the fundamental sustainability of the charity is also a consideration. Local authorities contribute just 20% of the £20M needed to pay for a normal lifeguard season – the remaining £16M comes from RNLI donations. Right now, our charity faces an expected £45M shortfall in funding by the end of the year because many of our fundraising activities have had to stop.

"No-one is to blame for the situation we find ourselves in. We’re asking everyone to help manage an impossible situation, so please follow our safety advice and think before you head to the coast.


"Mark Dowie

"RNLI Chief Executive"

Contact Us

If you would like to submit a query or provide more information on this story please get in touch below.

Please wait...
  • Up to 3 JPG or PNG images, 2MB max size
  • We will always endeavour to credit you when we publish your pictures.
  • By uploading you are agreeing to this non-exclusive reuse, royalty-free, across all Pirate FM platforms, which extends to our partner broadcasters.
  • You retain copyright to all images.
  • If you would like to send us a video, please upload to YouTube or similar and paste the video URL into the message above.
Email Icon

Sign up for exclusive news, competitions and offers.
Proper Local News updates from Pirate FM

Suggested articles

Coronavirus: Scotland to keep two-metre rule and make face coverings in shops mandatory

National News: The two-metre rule is going to remain in place in Scotland - and wearing face coverings in shops will become mandatory on 10 July.

Wembley sister killings: Man arrested over deaths

National News: A man has been arrested over the deaths of two sisters who were found stabbed in a park in Wembley, north London.

Newer articles

Calls for support for coastal tourism in Cornwall

Cornwall News: It is feared businesses could be forced to close because of the coronavirus shutdown

68 dogs stolen in Cornwall and Devon last year

Cornwall News: Here is the list of breeds which are most at risk...

Older articles

Cornish hospital worker raises funds for PPE

Cornwall News: Felicity Pickup is raising funds in memory of her late mother, Lynda Carter

Looe Live! festival is postponed until 2021

Cornwall News: The three-day festival was due to go ahead on the 25th-27th of September 2020.

Most read

A30 closed after crash involving cyclist and lorry

Cornwall News: The air ambulance has been called to the scene

Man's body found on north Cornwall beach

Cornwall News: Police and paramedics were called amid concerns for a person's welfare

Pirate Extra Pirate 70s Escape LoveCornwall